Showing posts with label Gray Infrastructure. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gray Infrastructure. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 02, 2014

Construction Is Just The Beginning

Several years ago, Dr. Dana Clark, a friend of mine who teaches in the business school at Appalachian State University penned an article warning communities bent on building mega-facilities that the initial cost will be just a fraction of the overall cost.

Partially, this is because construction since WWII, according to the Urban Land Institute, has been designed only to last 20 to 30 years.  This may be why the DBAP has just undergone another renovation that probably exceeds its original construction cost twenty years ago.

This time though, the City of Durham is on the hook for no more than $12 million with the owners of the Durham Bulls picking up about $8 million and agreeing to a lease keeping the storied team until at least 2033.

I remember glares of awkwardness I got from some when I corrected the misimpression left with Minor League Baseball officials by other economic developers during a tour many years ago that the acclaimed ballpark was a privately-held initiative.

At least now it could be argued that a fraction will be, as well as responsibility for operation and revenue-sharing, a win-win for the City.

This renovation was more than a face lift.  It included a new video board with more than 3.8 million LEDs, 8,000 linear feet of drain pipe under the field, 14 dump trucks of infield clay, 164 clusters of lights, 189 dump trucks of sand on which to lay a new field and all new seats with higher backs.

A new club level (air-conditioned restaurant/bar/event space) will be open to skybox owners, patrons and to season ticket holders who purchase a club membership for an additional fee, well worth it during hot, humid summer nights.  It is also available to groups for $45 per person.

The opening pitch this week to the new season will use one of 8,568 baseballs the Bulls will go through this season, about eight to ten dozen every home game.

The renovations were accelerated rather than phased because Durham hosts the Triple A baseball All-Star Game this year including five days of events.

Initial construction is only the beginning when it comes to cultural infrastructure, including facilities.  DBAP, it can be argued, spurred redevelopment of the historic Old Bull and Lucky Strike factories as well as construction of three new buildings.  Here again, the portion for local government increased to around $100 million.

In time, the local governments here will recoup some of the investment in increased property taxes, minus the impact of tenants dislocated from other parts of Durham.

As a baseball fan, I enjoyed watching the team in the now restored historic DAP north of city center, but given the alternative of losing the team, I think building the new ballpark just south of city center was our only option.

Built to look historic, the DBAP fits seamlessly with the historic built-scape part of Durham’s sense of place and has been leveraged through relentless community destination marketing into visitor-centric economic and cultural development that has repaid its original cost.

I’m not sure taxpayers would go along with cultural facilities like this if they knew the eventual lifetime costs, especially in destinations where it seems someone went shopping for culture one day and bought one of everything.

Cultural facilities, if tied to the indigenous distinctiveness of a community, are as important as any other type of infrastructure.

But as a friend of mine explained at the meeting of a state business lobby held in Durham last week, all too often the private sector refuses now to pay for public infrastructure because it sees it as a transfer rather than as the economic lifeblood it is.

At least the owners of the Durham Bulls seem to view it as a partnership.

Wednesday, July 03, 2013

Green Infrastructure Is By Definition Moderate

Friends and readers of this blog often kid me that based on some of the topics in this blog, I often appear more progressive than moderate, as I claim.

I can see their point.  Moderates are eclectic in their views by nature.  But reading closely they will see that while I am passionate about green infrastructure, I often kid “eco-Talibans.”  I prefer bans such that result in recycling and recovery to those on consumer use.

I also believe biotech, or genetically modified, foods (GMO) can be extremely beneficial and not just because I live in Durham, NC, a center for biotechnology research, development and entrepreneurs.

I am also wary of mainframe solutions or one-size-fits all approaches institutionalized by regulations, uninformed by or restricted from practicality and inflexible to the spirit in which they were created.

I am particularly intrigued with solutions forged across seemingly ideological divides such as the case made for green infrastructure over gray infrastructure in a white paper published last month by scientists for The Dow Chemical Company, Shell, Swiss Re and Unilever in conjunction with The Nature Conservancy.

These organizations have unique histories.  About the time Dow was founded in Michigan in 1897, the business that pioneered bulk oil tankers in 1892 was being renamed Shell.  Swiss Re, a wholesale reinsurance pioneer against catastrophes, took on the hazards of operating railroads, following insuring the conveyance of visitors to the World’s Fair in Chicago.

At the time, Unilever had just created Lifebuoy Soap and was launching Sunlight flakes to revolutionize household cleaning.  Two decades later The Nature Conservancy (TNC) found roots first as a society for ecologists to “publish research and pursue an agenda to preserve natural areas.”

World War I had started and baseball slugging legend Babe Ruth began his career as a pitcher in Boston.  Officials in New York State had protected the Adirondacks and Cornell professor Liberty Hyde Bailey published The Holy Earth, elevating conservation stewardship to an ethical imperative.

Bailey had been born on the shores of Lake Michigan, 168 miles west and south of where Dow was founded - and is still headquartered - near Saginaw Bay on Lake Huron.  In 1908, he headed President Theodore Roosevelt’s national Country Life Commission.

L.H. Bailey died in 1952 when I was shy of four years old,  two years after The Ecological Society of America had been renamed The Nature Conservatory and less than three years before the organization founded the first “land preservation fund.”

Seadrift, Texas lies roughly midway between Houston and San Antonio, encompassed by the Aransas National Wildlife Refuge which protects it from the Gulf of Mexico.  Dow’s 4,700 acre plant in North Seadrift was established in 1954 by Union Carbide which it assumed as a subsidiary in 2001.

The two companies had been founded a year apart but Dow took a special interest in the Seadrift plant not because it makes plastics for wiring and drip irrigation or glycols for antifreeze and fabrics, but for its use of green infrastructure.

To expand in 1996, regulations required expanded water treatment facilities that would cost $40 million.  But an engineer, possibly inspired by witnessing the power of wetlands in the surrounding wildlife refuge, staked his career on an unconventional solution, construction of a wetland next to the plant.

At $1.4 million, it was far less expensive and now treats 5 million gallons of water per day while meeting all regulatory standards.  As a bonus it provides habitat for wildlife.  One of the few downsides, as noted in the white paper, is that it first required a 1 to 2 year pilot project and it covers 110 acres as opposed to 4-5 acres for a treatment plant.

Dow is currently taking this tactical success to a strategic level and re-evaluating the feasibility of green infrastructure substitutes to a number of its gray infrastructure practices.  The paper also discussed a project in Oman where Shell is using commercial wetlands to treat water from oil drilling.

The white paper also gives a SWOT analysis (strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats) of green infrastructure, an overview of risk management solutions, as well as recommendations for how to make green infrastructure alternatives scalable.

Experts from Swiss Re have a special purpose for their involvement.  The company is in the business of managing risks, including that from global climate change, for which it has been a harbinger.  While many in high office hold solutions to that issue hostage, the free market is taking it very seriously.

Officials in my adopted home of Durham are working hard to deploy green infrastructure by taking a page from its past.  As can be seen by torrential downpours here of late, the city’s park, many of which were created on floodplains, also serve as giant retention ponds to slow and cleanse run-off.

Now in an effort to purify two of Durham’s urban streams, Ellerbe and South Ellerbe creeks, as well as a Durham lake created in the 1970s as a water supply for Raleigh located further downstream, storm water officials are proposing to create a wetland where an abandoned fitness center sits in the floodplain.

The proposed site sits at a low spot that drains nearly 480 acres of storm water runoff from Downtown and the lower part of the historic Trinity Park neighborhood.  It would cleanse this water of pollutants gathered from the impervious surface of the urban core and then slowly release them to control flooding.

Hopefully, when complete, The Dow Chemical Company’s strategic assessment of a holistic, company-wide application of green infrastructure applications will include full-cost accounting.  To fully address sustainability, it will have to not only offset the company’s footprint on the environment but give back.

As its founder, Herbert H. Dow. once remarked – “If you can’t do it better, why do it?”  Companies may never be able to outperform nature, but there is a stewardship obligation to first, do no harm.”

As disheartening as it is to see those in high office try to undo stewardship, I am heartened by what may become the full embrace of the marketplace.